Top 5 Reasons Green Card Renewal Applications are Rejected

Top 5 Reasons Green Card Renewal Applications are Denied

Before you know it, 10 years have flown by and it’s time to submit your Green Card renewal application.

According to the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS), green card holders can renew their 10-year Green Card within 6 months of its expiration date.

As you probably know, getting a Green Card is not easy.

Link: The Comprehensive Guide on How to Get a Green Card

Fortunately, the Green Card renewal process is often much simpler than the initial Green Card application. We know this because hundreds of immigrants have used SimpleCitizen to create and submit their own Green Card renewal applications. Preparing your application with the support of immigration professionals can help you avoid expensive and/or time-consuming mistakes, and can even help you avoid an application denial. 

While a Green Card Renewal denial is fairly rare, it does happen. If you choose to prepare your application on your own, please consider avoiding these 5 most common mistakes that can lead to a potential rejection or denial:

5. You were “Ordered Removed”

If you were ordered removed from the United States, your green card renewal is more likely to be denied. You are ordered removed if at least one of the following has happened to you:

• A judge ordered you deported or removed
• You signed a stipulated removal order
• You were at the border, and immigration officials completed Expedited Removal paperwork on you
  (Note: This is not simply being refused entry)

Also note that you are not considered “ordered removed” simply if your visa category is Z11, Z13, Z14, or Z15. These categories are based on a “suspension of deportation” or “suspension of removal” which is different from being ordered removed.

4. You’ve committed a crime

If you have committed a felony or misdemeanor, the best course of action is to seek advice from a licensed immigration attorney before filing to renew your green card. If you speak with an immigration attorney, you are much more likely to successfully obtain a renewed green card.

3. You submitted an incomplete application

Be careful to read all the instructions. These 4 parts of the green card renewal application are often missed:

• Remember to sign in all the right places.
• Be sure to attach all required evidence (requested photocopies of official documents).
• Make sure to pay the I-90 filing fee.
• Be sure to attend your scheduled biometrics appointment.

As long as you read and follow the instructions carefully, you shouldn’t have to worry.

A few weeks after submitting, you should receive an I-797 form from USCIS with information about your scheduled biometrics appointment. Failing to attend a scheduled biometrics appointment may result in the application being denied. 

2. You gave incorrect information

Make sure everything on your application is filled out as accurately as possible.

At your biometric services appointment, USCIS will ask you to re-affirm under penalty of perjury that the information you provided is complete and true. Your application  may be denied if USCIS finds any false information.

1. You submitted the wrong Green Card renewal form

There is a big difference between a regular Green Card, and a Green Card with conditions. Most notably, the length of validity each of the two cards has, as well as which form/application should be used for the card’s renewal. 

Here’s a brief summary: 

• Green Card (regular): Valid for 10 years;  must be renewed using Form I-90, Application to Replace Permanent Residency  ‍
• Conditional Green Card: Valid for 2 years, must be renewed  using Form I-751, Application to Remove Conditions. Renewal approval results in a 10-year card being issued. A conditional permanent resident should only submit the I-90 if their 2-year green card is lost, stolen, or damaged.

Click here if you want to learn more about conditional permanent residents.

Other Common Worries

Many applicants worry about financial problems, including bad credit scores or unpaid taxes, but it is uncommon for USCIS to deny a renewal Green Card application because of these issues.

However, unpaid taxes may lead to other problems. You could be fined and prosecuted which can make it more difficult to become a U.S. citizen.

What can I do if my application is denied?

You are not allowed to appeal a negative decision, but you may submit a motion to reopen or reconsider your case. By filing the motion, you’re requesting that the USCIS office reevaluate their decision.

If you file a motion to reopen, you must state the new information you will provide and include appropriate evidence. If you file a motion to reconsider, you instead must show that USCIS’s decision to deny your application was an incorrect application of law or policy and that USCIS’s decision was incorrect based on the evidence you provided when you filed your application. For more information, see this page.

Note: If the USCIS denies your application because of an error by SimpleCitizen, subject to certain conditions, we will refund your government application fees and the SimpleCitizen purchase price 100%. Here’s our refund policy.

How to avoid these mistakes

If you have any questions, you can contact us here.

If you want to learn more about how to renew your green card, read this guide: A Guide to Renewing Your Green Card. If you’re ready to jump right in and apply, get started here!

After you’ve successfully renewed your Green Card, we would love to hear your story. Please leave a review here and tell us about your experience.

‍